Investors fled to healthcare stocks for safety. Now insurance and hospital shares are plunging.
Published . Updated .
Key takeaways
Market Call
Think this story will push the stock up or down over the next three trading days? Make a free call and see what other readers think. Points are play money with no cash value.
Get these market calls by email
The week's biggest market-moving stories, Congress trades and Trump posts, with the tickers they touch. Free, one email a week.
Free. We only use your email to send the digest and never sell or share it. See our privacy policy.
Shares of UnitedHealth, Humana and CVS Health declined this week in light of a new Medicare for All proposal
Directly affected
- HUM Humana+14.3% 30d
Named in this report.
- CVS Cvs Health+3.8% 30d
Named in this report.
- UNH Unitedhealth Group+6.0% 30d
Named in this report.
Indirectly affected
- XLV Health Care Select Sector SPDR
Health Care Select Sector SPDR: it holds drugmakers and health companies. Linked by “healthcare” (pharma and health) in this story.
- XBI SPDR S&P Biotech ETF
SPDR S&P Biotech ETF: it holds drugmakers and health companies. Linked by “healthcare” (pharma and health) in this story.
- XLF Financial Select Sector SPDR+3.0% 12d
Financial Select Sector SPDR: it holds insurers. Linked by “insurance” (insurers) in this story.
- LLY Eli Lilly and+25.1% 30d
Eli Lilly and (pharmaceutical preparations): drugmakers move with drug pricing, approvals and health policy. Linked by “healthcare” (pharma and health) in this story.
- JNJ Johnson & Johnson+12.1% 30d
Johnson & Johnson (pharmaceutical preparations): drugmakers move with drug pricing, approvals and health policy. Linked by “healthcare” (pharma and health) in this story.
- PFE Pfizer+5.2% 30d
Pfizer (pharmaceutical preparations): drugmakers move with drug pricing, approvals and health policy. Linked by “healthcare” (pharma and health) in this story.
- MRK Merck+3.5% 30d
Merck (pharmaceutical preparations): drugmakers move with drug pricing, approvals and health policy. Linked by “healthcare” (pharma and health) in this story.
- CB Chubb
Chubb (fire, marine and casualty insurance): insurers pay claims and price policies around events like this. Linked by “insurance” (insurers) in this story.
Price reaction, T-5 to T+3
| Ticker | T-5 | T-3 | T-1 | T0 | T+1 | T+2 | T+3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HUM | +18.32% | +16.45% | base | +4.17% | after close | after close | after close |
| CVS | +11.59% | +7.11% | base | +2.19% | after close | after close | after close |
| UNH | +23.36% | +17.96% | base | +4.73% | after close | after close | after close |
| XLV | +6.43% | +4.39% | base | +1.21% | after close | after close | after close |
| XBI | +4.51% | +0.86% | base | -0.50% | after close | after close | after close |
| XLF | +5.54% | +2.68% | base | +0.55% | after close | after close | after close |
| LLY | +6.91% | +4.75% | base | +0.66% | after close | after close | after close |
| JNJ | +7.01% | +4.30% | base | +1.85% | after close | after close | after close |
| PFE | +4.82% | +3.23% | base | +1.03% | after close | after close | after close |
| MRK | +11.32% | +8.02% | base | +2.57% | after close | after close | after close |
| CB | +1.48% | +1.42% | base | +1.81% | after close | after close | after close |
Closing-price change versus T-1, the last close before the story. T0 to T+3 fill in after each market close. Prices: Alpaca IEX.
Shares of UnitedHealth, Humana and CVS Health declined this week in light of a new Medicare for All proposal
Source: MarketWatch
This story
| Company | When | Move | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| CB | that day | +1.81% | still updating |
| CB | three days earlier | +1.42% | final price |
| CB | five days earlier | +1.48% | final price |
| CVS | that day | +2.19% | still updating |
| CVS | three days earlier | +7.11% | final price |
| CVS | five days earlier | +11.59% | final price |
| HUM | that day | +4.17% | still updating |
| HUM | three days earlier | +16.45% | final price |
| HUM | five days earlier | +18.32% | final price |
| JNJ | that day | +1.85% | still updating |
| JNJ | three days earlier | +4.30% | final price |
| JNJ | five days earlier | +7.01% | final price |
| LLY | that day | +0.66% | still updating |
| LLY | three days earlier | +4.75% | final price |
| LLY | five days earlier | +6.91% | final price |
| MRK | that day | +2.57% | still updating |
| MRK | three days earlier | +8.02% | final price |
| MRK | five days earlier | +11.32% | final price |
| PFE | that day | +1.03% | still updating |
| PFE | three days earlier | +3.23% | final price |
| PFE | five days earlier | +4.82% | final price |
| UNH | that day | +4.73% | still updating |
| UNH | three days earlier | +17.96% | final price |
| UNH | five days earlier | +23.36% | final price |
| XBI | that day | -0.50% | still updating |
| XBI | three days earlier | +0.86% | final price |
| XBI | five days earlier | +4.51% | final price |
| XLF | that day | +0.55% | still updating |
| XLF | three days earlier | +2.68% | final price |
| XLF | five days earlier | +5.54% | final price |
| XLV | that day | +1.21% | still updating |
| XLV | three days earlier | +4.39% | final price |
| XLV | five days earlier | +6.43% | final price |
Trades by members of Congress and officials in the stocks in this story
- Rep. Rohit Khanna sold Cvs Health (CVS) (held by a spouse), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 4 Sep 2026. That is 77 days before publication. Filed 7 Oct 2026. View the filing.
- Donald J Trump, an executive branch official, sold Cvs Health (CVS), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 1 Sep 2026. That is 80 days before publication. Filed 19 Nov 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. Rohit Khanna sold Cvs Health (CVS) (held by a spouse), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 24 Aug 2026. That is 88 days before publication. Filed 4 Sep 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar sold Unitedhealth Group (UNH), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 24 Sep 2026. That is 57 days before publication. Filed 7 Oct 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. Kevin Hern sold Unitedhealth Group (UNH) (jointly held), worth $15,001 - $50,000 on 23 Sep 2026. That is 58 days before publication. Filed 13 Oct 2026. View the filing.
- Donald J Trump, an executive branch official, sold Unitedhealth Group (UNH), worth $15,001 - $50,000 on 11 Sep 2026. That is 70 days before publication. Filed 19 Nov 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. David J. Taylor sold Eli Lilly (LLY), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 3 Nov 2026. That is 17 days before publication. Filed 12 Nov 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. Gilbert Cisneros bought Eli Lilly (LLY), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 20 Oct 2026. That is 31 days before publication. Filed 10 Nov 2026. View the filing.
- Donald J Trump, an executive branch official, sold Eli Lilly (LLY), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 10 Sep 2026. That is 71 days before publication. Filed 19 Nov 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. Rohit Khanna sold Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) (held by a spouse), worth $15,001 - $50,000 on 7 Oct 2026. That is 44 days before publication. Filed 5 Nov 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. Thomas H. Kean Jr sold Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 30 Sep 2026. That is 51 days before publication. Filed 30 Oct 2026. View the filing.
- Rep. Rohit Khanna bought Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) (held by a spouse), worth $1,001 - $15,000 on 25 Sep 2026. That is 56 days before publication. Filed 7 Oct 2026. View the filing.
Public disclosure filings, not a recommendation. The filing link is the source document. News use of these reports still sits under 5 U.S.C. § 13107(c).
This story
12 out of 100Price not final
“Investors fled to healthcare stocks for safety. Now insurance and hospital shares are plunging.” scores 12 out of 100. The score uses 1 source. The price is not final yet.